BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese

BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese is the perfect ooey-gooey Hawaiian style grilled cheese sandwich. Delicious!

I was reading an article last week that mentioned that if you add any ingredients to a grilled cheese, other than cheese, than it’s not really a grilled cheese.  I didn’t really get it. If you add stuff, but still have cheese, and still ‘grill’ it, why isn’t it grilled cheese?  I have a feeling this is a widely debated topic, however, I will still refer to any cheesy sandwich as grilled cheese, and also mention the additions, such as this BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese.

BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese is the perfect ooey-gooey Hawaiian style grilled cheese sandwich. Delicious!

Not too long ago I was making a similar dish, only inside a quesadilla. I thought that this combination would be delicious piled into a sandwich and grilled to perfection.  Moist white meat shredded chicken, coated in savory sweet BBQ sauce, delicious juicy pineapple slices, and rich extra sharp cheddar cheese….so perfect.  While we don’t eat chicken, one of my friends was happy to be the guinea pig and try this out for me.  Not only did she say this was the best grilled cheese she had ever eaten, but she also said that she would love to try this combination of ingredients every way possible…on a quesadilla, on a bun, on a bagel…you know, the usual.  If you are scared of bread (not me, I love carbs), then you could also just take all these ingredients and throw them on top of some lettuce…actually, I am going to do that…stay tuned for that blog post.

BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese is the perfect ooey-gooey Hawaiian style grilled cheese sandwich. Delicious!

As with any grilled cheese sandwich, make sure you use a delicious pure cheese…not of this fake shredded cheese with tons of additives. Sure, it’s okay to use in other recipes, but when the cheese is really standing out in the recipe, you need it to taste great and also melt really well. pre-shredded cheeses have additives so that they don’t clump together in the bag, but you need the cheese to melt together so pre-shredded cheese really isn’t ideal for melting. Do yourself a favor and buy some good cheese!

BBQ Chicken & Pineapple Grilled Cheese
  1. 2 boneless, skinless chicken breasts
  2. 1 cup sweet and spicy BBQ sauce, divided
  3. 8 slices good quality bread, such as sourdough
  4. 2 cups extra sharp cheddar cheese, grated on the largest setting
  5. 12 thinly sliced pineapple strips (you could also use canned pineapple, sliced thinly)
  6. butter
  7. nonstick spray
  1. 1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Place chicken breasts into an oven safe baking dish, spread 1/2 cup BBQ sauce over chicken; Coat chicken with sauce. Bake for 20 minutes or until cooked through.
  2. 2.Remove from oven and shred chicken with 2 forks. In a large bowl combine shredded chicken and 1/2 cup BBQ sauce; mix until evenly coated.
  3. 3. Taking 8 slices of bread, butter one side of each slice (only one side). Place bread butter side down, and lay all slices out in front of you. Spread 1/4 cup of cheese onto 4 slices of bread. On top of that cheese, spread one fourth of the chicken mixture onto each slice. Add 3 pineapple slices on top of the chicken, then top with the remaining cheese (should be about 1/4 cup on top of each slice). Taking the slices that have only been buttered, place them on top of the cheese layer, butter facing out. Press down with hand or spatula.
  4. 4. Heat a skillet or grill pan over medium heat and spray with non stick spray. Place 2 sandwiches butter side down on the pan, and cook for 3-4 minutes, or until browned. Flip and cook on the other side for 1-2 minutes or until browned. *Careful, they tend to cook fast on the second side. Repeat these steps until all sandwiches are cooked.
  5. 5. Cit sandwiches in half and serve immediately.
  6. Note: These can also be made in the crock pot: Spray crock pot, add chicken, BBQ sauce (1 cup), and pineapple. Cook for 4 hours on high. Remove chicken, shred. Follow directions above from step #3.
Domestic Superhero


You can also connect with me here:

Thanks for visiting!

- Allyson


The Pinworthy Projects Link Party #55


Yay! Another week down and we are almost into March, can you believe it?! I am so impressed with all the link ups lately, and our party is getting huge! Tell all your friends about it, because you have the chance to be featured across 3 blogs and that is a lot of great exposure! You also have the chance to meet other awesome bloggers and check out what they are sharing! I love finding new blogs to follow through this party, and y’all give me amazing content to pin, so THANK YOU! In case you haven’t been around Domestic Superhero, this is what you missed!   Strawberry Biscones with … more

Garlic Ginger Spinach


Over the last few weeks we have been doing a lot of juicing at my house. Most of our juices contain tons of spinach and ginger.  While I love ginger, if you put too much ginger in the juicer it seriously ruins the juice. It’s crazy because I LOVE ginger, but if you put too much in the juice, it’s way too over powering…to the point it actually burns my throat.  Anyway, so we have had our fridge stocked with healthy veggies and when I decided it was time to eat actual food, instead of just drink juice all day, I decided to make this delicious Garlic Ginger Spinach. We had tons of extra … more

Strawberry Biscones with Sweet Orange Glaze


For the last few weeks we have been doing a lot of juicing at my house. I decided I wasn’t such a fan of strawberries in the juice recipes, so I had a couple pints of strawberries hanging out in the fridge. I woke up on Saturday morning with the urge to use them, because they were on the brink of going bad, and I hate wasting food.  So I decided to make some strawberry scones, which I thought was a great idea…until I was in the middle of making them, and realized I added way too much heavy cream.  I was about to toss them because I figured they would be nasty, but I just rolled with … more

Pinworthy Projects Link Party #54


Happy Friday, y’all! I can’t believe we only have ONE more week left in February…where did the time go?!  Things have been crazy over here, but I am so ready for spring to get here already – come on! Last week’s party was AMAZING, as usual, and I am sharing a ton of features. There were SO many awesome things linked up. I have also been sharing lots of your links on social media, so be sure to follow Domestic Superhero on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest!! If you haven’t been around this week, here is what you missed…   Roasted Vegetable Frittata and Easy Feeding with … more

Easy Feeding with Graco® Swivi Seat™ Highchair


Having a baby is such an exciting time, so exciting that sometimes it’s easy to forget to eat, or to not be able to sneak a bite in while feeding your precious little one. When I heard about the Graco® Swivi Seat™ Highchair, I was thrilled that they wanted to sponsor a post for me to share their product. The Graco® Swivi Seat™ Highchair is revolutionary, because it swivels 360 degrees. This is awesome because I can set it at the table between my husband and I, and actually swivel it back and forth so that both of us can take turns feeding Everett (our 7 month old).  This way be both … more

Roasted Vegetable Frittata


I really love making frittata’s for several reasons, however, the main reason would be that they are absolutely delicious.  Frittatas can pretty much handle whatever veggies or meats you want to throw at them, and I often find myself making them when I have extra eggs, vegetables, or cheese. I’ve never met a frittata I haven’t liked.  The key to making a great frittata is adding a bit of dairy – full fat, not watery skim milk. I have made them using whole milk, cream, half and half, and also greek yogurt. Whatever you use, make sure it has fat.  A frittata is very healthy, so … more

The Pinworthy Projects Link Party #53


Wow, we had a seriously awesome party last week with way over 400 links!!! Y’all are amazing – keep the links coming! I went through and pinned a ton of things and am sharing a bunch today as well! It’s so fun looking through everything!  Here is what I shared on Domestic Superhero this week:   Oreo Bomb Truffles / Easy Leftover Herb Butter Now for this week’s features!!!    A Busy Mom’s Guide to Meal Planning / Lavender Lotion Bars    Strawberry Wonton Cups / Melt in Your Mouth Blueberry Cake with Lemon Glaze   10 Best Money Saving and Making … more

Easy Leftover Herb Butter


I love cooking with fresh herbs, but I often find myself tossing the leftovers once they go bad. It’s hard to use them all up when you just need a bunch for one recipe.  I decided to solve this problem by blending my leftover herbs into butter, and then freezing it.  Easy leftover herb butter is super quick to make, and if you freeze it, you can cut off a chunk whenever you need it. I love slicing off a few medallions and throwing them on top of a loaf of bread while it bakes. You get the most delicious herb buttered bread once it’s cooked.  You can use the herb butter on … more

Oreo Bomb Truffles


A couple of weeks ago, I decided to make these Oreo Truffle Bombs for a Super Bowl Party we were attending. I actually had them for the first time a few years prior, at the same friend’s house while they were hosting a party. I asked the girl who had made them her recipe, and it’s turned out to be SO easy. I’ve made Oreo Bomb Truffles several times since, and they are always a big hit. Some of these are a little crazy with the sprinkles, because of course my 4 year old helper LOVES sprinkles.  The truth is, you can top these balls with anything or nothing. I’ve made them with crushed … more