This Best Ever Homemade Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing is cool, creamy, tangy, and full of chunky blue cheese crumbles. It’s incredibly easy and delicious!
Guys…this is seriously the BEST EVER homemade chunky blue cheese dressing. I know, I know; tons of recipes claim to be the ‘best ever’, but believe me when I say…this is THE BEST EVER Chunky Blue Cheese. Blue cheese is just one of those things, you either like it or you hate it. I happen to LOVE it, and will pretty much put it on whatever I can. There have been many times when I have thought that whatever I am eating is just a vessel for the sauce or dip. This is why blue cheese makes the perfect veggie dip…because all you can taste is the blue cheese. If you are a fan of the cool, creamy, tangy, chunky blue cheese, then you HAVE to try this. Seriously..make this right now.
With the exception of the actual blue cheese, you most likely have everything for this chunky blue cheese dressing in your pantry or fridge, which is another reason I love it so much. When I was making it, I really wanted to use buttermilk, but guess what? I didn’t have any. So what to do? Just make buttermilk yourself – all it takes is some milk and vinegar – easy peasy. This homemade chunky blue cheese dressing would also be fabulous on your favorite wedge salad, or wings, or a buffalo chicken lettuce wrap or sandwich….or in a straw…however you eat it, it will be fantastic – I promise.
I do have a few tips for you though – one, make this Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing and let it sit in the fridge AT LEAST four hours. Please, please, please. If you don’t follow this very important tip, this may just turn out not to be the best ever, and I can’t have that. It must be the best ever, so you have to let this bad boy meld it’s flavors in the fridge at least four hours. The second tip, use real blue cheese and crumble it yourself. You can by chunks of this stuff in the produce/deli/cheese section of your grocery store. If you absolutely can’t find it because you live in the middle of nowhere, then fine, use pre-crumbled blue cheese…it might not be as good, but it will still be delicious.
This Best Ever Homemade Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing is cool, creamy, tangy, and full of chunky blue cheese crumbles. It's incredibly easy and delicious!
- 1/3 cup milk
- 1 tsp white vinegar
- 5 ounces blue cheese , crumbled
- 1/3 cup + 1 TBS sour cream
- 1/4 cup mayonnaise
- 4 tsp white wine vinegar
- 1/2 tsp granulated white sugar
- 1/4 tsp garlic powder
- 1/8 tsp freshly ground black pepper
- dash of salt
-
In a medium bowl mix milk and 1 tsp white vinegar; let sit for 5 minutes, stir. Add crumbled blue cheese to mixture, and mash with a fork until they are well combined.
-
Add sour cream, mayonnaise, white wine vinegar, sugar, garlic powder, black pepper, and salt; mix with fork to combine well.
-
Pour into mason jar or other container and seal tightly. Let set in fridge for at least 4 hours. Remove, stir, and serve on your favorite foods!
If you have buttermilk, you can use 1/3 cup in place of the milk and 1 tsp white vinegar.
Will last in the fridge for up to 30 days in a sealed container.
Makes just under 2 cups.
Like sauces and dips as much as I do? Check out these other recipes from Domestic Superhero:
Thanks for visiting!
– Allyson
Doris says
Hi Allyson!
I just found your site when searching for the blue cheese dressing recipe—-Yes, this a winner but I ramped mine up a tad with actual crushed garlic and a dash of hot sauce. Hope to get some more tasty ideas from what looks like to be a wonderful food sharing website. Thanks a bunch!
Allyson says
You are so welcome! Those sound like amazing additions! I will have to try that when I make it next time. Thank you for coming by and I hop eyou enjoy my recipes!!!
Erin says
Why white wine vinegar? Don’t have any so just checking! Thanks!
Randy says
Vinegar in the milk takes the place of buttermilk. The dressing needs the hit of acidity in some form.
Beth Wilson says
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Thank you so much for sharing! 🙂
Cherie says
Made this today and it turned out great! I had buttermilk on hand so used it. Great and easy recipe!
Allyson says
SO happy you loved it! Thanks!
Reg says
Can I substitute Miracle Whip in place of mayonnaise? Miracle Whip is our product of choice.
Allyson says
it will definitely give the dressing a different taste, but if you like it, it might turn out tasty!
Donna says
can you make it with whit vinegar?
Yvonne says
Absolutely the best blue cheese dressing! Made it yesterday AND again today and I was surprised how easy it is to make with ingredients I already had on hand the only thing I had to run out and buy was the blue cheese! No more of the ready made stuff at the store. Your homemade version is a household favorite. Thank you for sharing 😊
Sue says
I can now stop looking for the best blue cheese dressing because I have found it with this one. Delicious although next time I will add a crushed garlic clove rather than garlic powder as I like a stronger garlic flavour.
Julie says
I allergic to blue cheese, may try parm. Will let you how than works out
Allyson says
Yes, let me know!
Natalie Hogan says
I made this last night for xmas eve– we used St. Agur blue cheese, so it was quite decadent and very delicious. We served it over kale salad with golden beets and apples– highly recommend!!! 10/10
Gail says
I made this tonight following the recipe with the exception of adding fresh garlic and a squeeze of lemon juice. I was licking the spoon it was so good. I will definitely bookmark for the future. Yum yum 👅
Allyson says
Ohhhhh yeah!!!!! I love it too 🙂
Tracy says
This was amazing. I used avocado mayo and left out the sugar. I will never buy the bottled junk again. Thank you for a great recipe.
Allyson says
What a great idea with the avocado mayo!!!! Sounds delicious! No bottle compares to the homemade recipe! It’s TOO good! Happy New Year!
Mama Cindy Rogofsky says
What in heck ever happened to Hellman’s blue cheese? I used to love that and my supermarket stopped selling it along with Sally Sherman potato salad?
Allyson says
I have never tried that, but I bet this one is better! Try it and let me know 🙂
Carmen says
I made this earlier today and I thought it was great! I decided to stir and test it after a 4-5 hours of sitting in the fridge, to my disappointment…it is completely runny, It is no longer thick and chunky, any thought? I am prepping for our super bowl party tomorrow, but I might have to start over with this. BTW, I used buttermilk.
Carmen
Allyson says
Hmmm, did you remix it? I usually let mine sit overnight and it gets even thicker.
Randy says
This is a delicious dressing. Used Roquefort. The tiny amount of sugar really evens it out, but trying it pre and post sugar, I think I liked it better without it. More tang! Used a very small amount of crushed garlic.
This recipe has ruined store bought.
Allyson says
Isn’t it SO good?!?! I can never buy store bought anymore either!!!
Vicky Winteringham says
Don’t know if this really is the best ever blue cheese dressing, but I made it yesterday and I won’t be looking for another with which to compare it. Fabulous. All one needs is a bunch of leafy greens and this dressing. Heaven. Thanks so much.
Allyson says
Yessssss!!!!
Deb says
This really is delish! I didn’t have sour cream so substituted low fat Greek yogurt. Nice and thick and very tasty!
Pam says
I don’t have white wine vinegar. Can I sub rice vinegar or white wine?
Allyson says
Pam- I am not sure as I have not tried those substitutions, however white vinegar is found in almost all grocery/convenience/pharmacy stores!
Mandy Williams says
Recipe lists white vinegar and white wine vinegar…so both? Can’t wait to try it.
Linda says
I make it without the sugar and it’s Delish! Can we get breakdown on ingred list so I can figure out how many weight watcher points per serving?
Allyson says
So glad you like it! What do you mean a breakdown on ingredient list? The ingredient list is in the post.
Dick says
Bought myself a pellet smoker so put the first batch of pulled pork on to cook. Decided to get some blue cheese crumbles to put on top of sandwich. Than decided why not some bc dressing. Heck what a find I’ll be hard pressed to stop eating this stuff. Can’t wait for it to set and didnt….had to try it out. Pork will be done in another 4 hours and so will the dressing. Can’t wait! Thanks so much
Allyson says
So?!?! How did it turn out? Can’t wait to hear!
Mike Minor says
Blue cheese is my favorite dressing. I had never made it before, but I followed the directions as per the recipe. This was, by far, the absolute best Blue Cheese dressing I have ever had.I’m putting some on a wedge salad and Angus New York strips, tonight. Thanks for sharing!!!
Allyson says
So happy you loved it as much as we do! It definitely lives up to the name! Enjoy!
Jim Pavshak says
Thanks for the recipe Allyson! I just made my first batch of it. I used 1 minced garlic clove in place of the powder. I licked the mixing bowl clean! Now it’s a 4 hour wait.. 🙂
Thanks again!
Jim
Allyson says
Jim – I know how you feel…I actually have to stop myself from making it because I WILL EAT IT ALL!!! Too good! So happy you liked it!
Jim Pavshak says
Hi Allyson.
I made this recipe a couple times now. I absolutely love it!! I do substitute a clove of fresh garlic for the garlic powder.
Thank you so much!
Jim
Allyson says
I am so happy you love it Jim! We make it all the time too!
Jack B. Nimble says
Try some finely chopped dill for a wonderful twist. I also use real garlic when possible too. Worcestershire sauce also adds a bit more umami to it.
Maryg says
Sorry if I’ve rated this before, but it is SO good. It turns out perfectly every single time. Delicious!
Allyson says
Thank you so much!! We love it too!
Marian says
Just made this for a special anniversary date night in. It’s wonderful tasting. I don’t think I’ll ever buy this dressing again. Thank you.
Allyson says
So glad you loved it! Happy Anniversary!
Natalie says
This is the best recipe I’ve made for blue cheese dressing and I’ve tried many! I think one of the keys to this recipe is the first 2 steps, letting the milk and vinegar sit for 5 min and then mixing the blue cheese together with the “buttermilk” – this is DELISH! I made it exactly as written. I used Hellman’s mayo (store didn’t have Dukes which I usually use) and Boars Head Blue Cheese. Yummy!!! 5star recipe!
Allyson says
YES!!!! I am so glad you loved it and I totally agree!!!
Jeannine Firestenberg says
This sounds like a great recipe. I’m trying to make everything from scratch and not use store bought condiments. But this recipe calls for mayo, and that is a store bought condiment. Do you know what I could use to replace the mayo?
Allyson says
Homemade mayo?
1 large egg yolk
1 1/2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
1 teaspoon white wine vinegar
1/4 teaspoon Dijon mustard
1/2 teaspoon salt plus more to taste
3/4 cup canola oil, divided
PREPARATION
Combine egg yolk, lemon juice, vinegar, mustard, and 1/2 teaspoon salt in medium bowl. Whisk until blended and bright yellow, about 30 seconds.
Using 1/4 teaspoon measure and whisking constantly, add 1/4 cup oil to yolk mixture, a few drops at a time, about 4 minutes. Gradually add remaining 1/2 cup oil in very slow thin stream, whisking constantly, until mayonnaise is thick, about 8 minutes (mayonnaise will be lighter in color). Cover and chill. do ahead Can be made up to 2 days ahead. Keep chilled.
GaryT says
Agree with those who suggest omitting the sugar. No need to “balance out” the “tang.” And using Miracle Whip would be heresy in my book.