Key lime pie turned into a mini dessert! Layer traditional pie fillings in shooter glasses for key lime pie shots; the perfect no-bake party dessert!
Key Lime Pie Shots are the perfect mini dessert that come together in no time. You can make these the morning of a party, then have them ready to go come party time!
If you love key lime pie as much as I do, you should also see my Key Lime Pie Dip and Skinny Mini Key Lime Pies! Key Lime Pie Shots are quick and simple to make, yet taste like they took hours to put together; everyone will love them!
How to make Key Lime Pie Shots:
**Scroll all the way down for full printable directions and ingredient list**
- Make the key lime pie filling first. Once that is set, layer the shot glasses (I like these plastic disposable shot glasses) with crushed graham crackers, pie filling, and then continue until you reach the top of the glass. Add a bit of whipped cream and sprinkle a few more graham cracker crumbs. Add a quarter of a lime wedge for garnish.
- Serve immediately or place into the fridge until time to serve.
Different ways to serve Key Lime Pie Shots:
No shot glasses? No problem. Use these plastic disposable shot glasses, or serve the mini key lime pie desserts in different glasses; a rocks glass or wine glass work great for these as well as a parfait glass or bowl. Layer just as stated above and serve!
Can I make them in advance?
Yes! Make the filling in advance but do not assemble the shot glasses until the day of serving.
Having the ingredients prepped makes for easy assembly the day the key lime pie shots are needed. Assemble the shots up to 6 hours before serving, and store in the fridge. Add whipped cream right before serving.
When to serve these mini desserts:
Key Lie Pie Shots are perfect for a potluck, dinner party, BUNCO party, holiday party, New Years Eve, Super Bowl event, or girls night! These would also be great at a BBQ with the little plastic disposable shot glasses.
Other desserts you might be interested in making:
- Key Lime Pie Dip is the perfect no-fuss dessert! Bring this to potluck or party and everyone will ask for the recipe!
- Strawberry Mousse – A sweet. creamy spring time berry dessert
- Skinny Mini Key Lime Pies are a healthier take on Key Lime Pie. Individual servings make portion control a cinch and they are just as delicious as the original!
- Honey Lime Fruit Salad is the perfect summer fruit salad!
- Slow Cooker Cranberry Cheesecake is made in the slow cooker and topped with the most delicious cranberry compote! Perfect holiday dessert!
- TWIX Cheesecake Bars with Chocolate & Caramel Drizzle are the ultimate left-over candy dessert! Whip these up for your next party!
Make sure you don’t miss a thing! Follow Domestic Superhero on:
Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest | TikTok | Email
For NEW RECIPES delivered straight to your inbox, signup for our email list!
Key lime pie turned into a mini dessert! Layer traditional pie fillings in shooter glasses for key lime pie shots; the perfect no-bake party dessert!
- 4 ounces 1/3 less fat cream cheese neufatchel cheese
- 14 ounces sweetened condensed milk
- 3 limes zest and juice set aside
- 15 graham crackers pulsed into crumbs
- whipped cream for topping
-
Using a stand mixer or electric mixer, combine cream cheese and condensed milk until well mixed. Add lime juice and half the lime zest; mix to combine.
-
Transfer to bowl and refrigerate for at least 2 hours, up to overnight.
-
Using your shooter glasses, layer dip/graham crackers, until you reach the top. Add whipped cream*, and lime zest. Garnish with lime wedge if desired. Repeat with all shooter glasses.
-
Refrigerate until serving, up to 6 hours before serving*
Makes 20+ shooters
- Will keep 6 hours in the fridge before serving.
- If not serving immediately, I would wait until serving time to add the whipped cream.
First published in November 2018. Updated April 2021.
Michelle says
What a fun party dessert! Definitely will try this…I love the key lime flavor!
Lawrence says
OMG so yummy. Only recently have a first (EVER) tried key lime pie. And the one I tried wasn’t even homemade and probably doesn’t hold a candle to this one. But I am in love with key lime pie – gotta make one myself now.
Catalina says
Oh my goodness! I want this right now! Such an elegant and delicious dessert!
Amy says
What a fun dessert! Love serving individual desserts!
Allison says
I’m making these for my husband – he LOVES key lime pie!
Toni | Boulder Locavore says
I love individual desserts! These are really AHH-mazing!
Toni | Boulder Locavore says
I love individual desserts! These look really AHH-mazing!
Erin | Dinners,Dishes and Dessert says
These would disappear in our house!
Krista says
I want this for dessert! It sounds refreshing!
Kara says
I love key lime pie, so I thought these were AMAZING! They are even creamier, and of course it’s fun to eat anything out of a tiny serving dish. It’s ok if we all ate two of them, right? haha!
sommer says
I looove key lime pie, and this just became my most favorite way of eating it!
April says
This is such a yummy and EASY dessert!
Jo says
Perfect for a quick party dessert! Love it!
Rosemary Petriello says
Can I make the filing a week or two ahead of time and freeze it?
Vikki says
Fantastic twist on one of my favorite desserts. So tasty!
Erin says
This Key Lime Pie Shots is such an exciting idea!
Amanda Livesay says
Love these for a party! They are so cute and so delicous!
Beth says
Yummy! These are such a fun and adorable idea! My daughter is going to love making these with me, so excited to make these very soon!
Sandra says
This is a really fun idea! My husband enjoyed it!
Catalina says
I need a dozen of these! I am drooling over these shots! Yummy!
Carla Crouch says
Does “three limes” mean 3 tiny key limes or 3 large limes?
Allyson says
I used key limes!
Krystle says
I love key lime pie, these are such a treat. I’ve eaten 3 so far today opps!