Earlier this week we celebrated my baby boy’s 3rd birthday (where did the time go?!), and even though we weren’t having a big party, I wanted to still make his actual day special. We had celebrated with family over Thanksgiving weekend, because it was more convenient than celebrating on a random Tuesday night, but these birthdays only come around once a year, and I wanted Austin to live it up! Since he loves M&M’s, baking cookies, and ice cream, I wanted to put them all together for a fun treat.
We started by baking the M&M cookies and then letting them completely cool. Next up was turning them into ice cream sandwiches. For my toddler I used regular vanilla bean ice cream and scooped about 1/3 of a cup onto one cookies, and then topped with the other cookie.
Since my husband and I wanted to indulge in the cookies, but not all the calories of the ice cream, we made ours with frozen vanilla Greek yogurt! I love using Greek yogurt in place of various creamy things because it adds a lot of nutritional value, and I can hardly ever tell a difference. I popped the little container of Vanilla Greek yogurt into the freezer for about 30 minutes, then spooned onto the cookie, and topped with the other cookie.
Both cookies turned out to be a HUGE hit with everyone! I made about 8 more to have on hand and stored them wrapped tight in the freezer! Now, we have M&M Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches available all the time! Total score! Not only did my son devour the sandwich, but then he sneakily ate about 10 M&M’s and an extra cookie!!!! I couldn’t really get upset though…they are totally delicious!
- One 12-ounce package of plain M&Ms
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 TBS cornstarch
- 3/4 tsp salt
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 3/4 cup brown sugar
- 3/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar
- 1 large egg
- 1 TBS vanilla extract
- Container of vanilla ice cream (size is dependent on how many sandwiches you would like to make)
- Container of vanilla greek yogurt, partially frozen* (size is dependent on how many sandwiches you would like to make)
- 1. In a bowl, mix together flour, cornstarch, salt and baking soda and set aside.
- 2. In a stand mixer (or using a hand mixer), cream together butter and both sugars on medium speed until light and fluffy (2-3 minutes). With the mixer on low, add in egg and vanilla. Return mixer to medium and mix until incorporated. Scrape sides if needed.
- 3. With the mixer on low, add dry ingredients gradually until dough forms. Fold in M&Ms by hand. 4. Refrigerate dough for at least 30 minutes. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F and line baking sheets with parchment paper or baking mat and set aside.
- 4. Form balls from approximately 1 tablespoon of dough. Bake for 9-11 minutes or until edges are just barely golden. Remove from oven and let cool for a couple of minutes on baking sheet before removing and placing on wire rack to finish cool.
- 5. Scoop about 1/3 cup of ice cream or yogurt onto cookie bottom side up, and then top with 2nd cookie (bottom side to ice cream). Repeat for desired number of cookies.
- 6. Eat and enjoy, or wrap tightly with foil or plastic wrap and store in freezer for later consumption.
- *for a small container of greek yogurt, pop into freezer for 30 minutes to an hour to make it partially frozen. You don't want it so hard that you can't scoop it, but you don't want it so loose that it doesn't hold the weight of the cookies.
Thanks for visiting!
– Allyson
Elizabeth@ Food Ramblings says
yum! now i’m craving an ice cream sandwich!
milenabarrett says
Wow! Now that’s yummy! I always make cookies this season with M&M’s, but I never made ice scream sandwiches- must try it!
Francine Morrell says
You can never go wrong with M&M’s!
Dyann says
are these cookies soft or crunchy?
Allyson says
Mine were nice and soft, but did harden up in the freezer a bit obviously. They were easy to eat though. You need to make sure you don’t overbake them if you want them soft!
Amy Lynn Desrosiers says
These look so delicious! I had never thought to make a healthier version!
Jennifer Brazil says
Wow those look so good and very easy to make too!
brett says
those look awesome!! and your son’s a cutie pie
Ave says
Wow, these look so delicious! Have to surprise my husband with them.
Pam W says
Those look delicious! I would like to have one of those now. I like how you made the filling.
bellanna3 says
These are so cute! Perfect sized for little hands too!
cynthial1956 says
I think I would be like your little one and be munching away on these. I love that there are M&M’s in the ice cream too!
Janeane Davis (@janeanedavis) says
My kids really like when I give them fresh baked cookies and let them make ice cream sandwiches. I will have to add the M and Ms for them.
Lisa says
We are totally making these this weekend.
The *New* Classy (@TheNewClassy) says
I love greek yogurt. This looks like a really good recipe. 🙂
Dawn Lopez (@dawnchats) says
OOh what a unique and scrumptious sounding idea! Thanks for sharing it with us, I might have to make these over the weekend!
Liz (@blueviolet) says
I’m going to try your tip with the yogurt. I would so have that if I could skinny it up a little bit, so thanks!
Deborah E says
This is such a great layout for advertising the M&M Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches. This is better than the ads we used to see on TV.
Danielle @ We Have It All says
OH! I’m going to make those tomorrow!
Mommy2Jam (Adrianne) says
These look really great, I like the ice cream sandwiches. I would never think to put greek yogurt and cookies together, by the looks of it your toddler ate it so it must be good! I will be breve and try that too! Oh and happy birthday to your little one. YES time goes by so so fast.
Mama to 5 BLessings says
oh my goodness that looks delicious, my kids would freak out over these! Thanks for sharing the recipe!
now at home mom says
these look delicious and so good! 🙂 love them!
Kristy says
Happy Birthday to your baby boy! My daughter is about to turn 1 this week and I’m trying to figure out where the time went too! I love the cookie sandwich idea plus the greek yogurt is perfect! #client
CrazyMom says
YUMMM.. What a fun idea; I always buy the ice cream sandwiches, never thought of making my own and they are sooo simple.Thanks for sharing, will be a hit at the next party
Katherine Bartlett (@KBWhiskey) says
These look so good. I buy stuff like these in the store all the time!
trisha says
Oh man, M&M cookie ice cream sandwiches are my FAVORITE
Lisa@ Cooking with Curls says
It is 4 degrees outside, and now I am craving ice cream sandwiches!! They look delicious, and so colorful 😉